I was never that impressed with the miniseries Identity Crisis when it came out back in 2004-5, but I wasn’t entirely sure why. Having reread it recently, I think I have it figured out (cover art by Michael Turner, all rights with current holder). And if anyone cares, full spoilers follow.
The short answer: “A love letter to the silver age” shouldn’t involve the rape and murder of a likeable Silver Age character or showing how all that Silver Age idealism is just a load of baloney.
The longer answer? Read on …
As the first issue opens, we have Elongated Man (Ralph Dibney) telling his fellow hero Firehawk about how much he loves his wife Sue. We also see Ray (The Atom) Palmer thrilled that his wife seems to be warming up to him again (she had an affair some years ago, then they divorced). We see about two pages of Sue preparing a party for him, then she’s killed and burned to death.
The Justice League rallies round, offering support, investigating the case and trying to figure how the world-class security they have for their families could have been breached. Ralph, no slouch of a detective himself, realizes the killer was Dr. Light and recruits a team to get that long-time JLA-foe. Wally West (this was back when he was still Flash) asks for an explanation. He learns that several years earlier, Light stumbled across Sue and, frustrated by his repeated defeats at the League’s hands, raped her.
But there’s much, much more! After the League takes him down, Light gloats that it’ll be easy to find Sue again, as she and Ralph don’t have secret identities. And he’ll find all their families and do the same! A worried Ralph convinces League sorceress-in-residence Zatanna to zap Light’s mind so he can’t do this again, which has the minor effect of turning Light from a formidable foe to a moron. Green Arrow tells Wally that the League has been wiping minds for years, every time a villain discovered their identity (which is, I note, Silver Age canon, they did it quite routinely when the villain didn’t lose their memory by accident), but this was a step further …and one too far for Batman, who objected, and had to get mindwiped about his memory of it.
A terrified Light hires Deathstroke to defend him and Deathstroke improbably takes out the entire League, only to lose when they counter-attack. But then Dr. Midnight, the surgeon turned super-hero performing the autopsy, reveals that based on his examination Sue was dead before her body burned.
More attacks on the Leaguers’ loved ones take place. Someone tries to strangle Jean, which leads to Ray rushing to protect her, and then to them falling back into bed together. Tim Drake’s (Robin at the time) father is killed by Captain Boomerang’s son. Everyone draws closer to the people they care about … and then Midnight discovers tiny footprints in Sue’s brain. Like the ones Ray Palmer would make if he’d used his atom-powers to shrink down, climb into her head and stomp around some.
But it turns out it’s not Ray, it’s Jean. Desperate to win Ray back, she figured that if she stole his tech and injured Sue (the death was an accident), he’d come rushing to protect her. Of course, it’s established at the start of the series that he still loves her madly (she left him, remember?) so a dinner invitation would have worked, but no problem—she’s crazy! She’s cuckoo! Stark raving bonkers! And winds up committed to Arkham Asylum (and would later become the new Eclipso, but that’s another story).
So there’s the plot. Next up, the holes.








