According to Ron DeSantis’ educational policies, discussions and lessons on race that make students uncomfortable are bad. Schools are rapidly adjusting to avoid any mention of race that might bring DeStalinist’s heavy hand down on them. However a Florida teacher showing a pro-confederacy video isn’t “cause for discipline” according to the school board; instead the teacher’s complaining about how it’s the board’s investigation that makes students uncomfortable around him and his fee-fees are hurt.
So apparently DeSantis’ fight against “indoctrination” in schools doesn’t extend to indoctrinating students with lies about the Confederacy. Heck it doesn’t extend to fighting indoctrination as long as it’s right-wing indoctrination. As Paul Campos says, you’re going to indoctrinate them in something, whether it’s “seceding to preserve the right to treat human beings as property is justifiable” or “equality is good, racism is bad.”
Over in Texas, Sen. Mayes Middleton sponsored a bill to let schools hire chaplains as mental-health counselors instead of professional counselors or social workers. And there’s no certification or other requirements the chaplains be qualified to counsel students. Middleton trotted out the usual cliches in a WaPo interview: we took god out of schools, everything went to pot!
Of course we didn’t take God out. Students can pray, form religious clubs, etc. so God’s still there. Efforts to revive school prayer are much more about showing non-Christian kids who’s in charge, just as school prayer and Bible readings in the 19th century were all about teaching Catholics and Jews this was a Protestant country (this was openly touted as a good thing, as covered in the book The Fourth R). As for making them godly, it didn’t stop good Christians from supporting Jim Crow or lynching black Americans.
Middleton tells the interviewer that separation of church and state is not a thing (it is). And while he insists chaplains are not going to proselytize, but the religious group backing the effort is all about proselytizing. And Middleton shot down an amendment to ban it. If counseling was the real concern, wouldn’t he put some effort into seeing the chaplains were qualified? Instead he approved an amendment to require certification, then it got stripped from the bill. Go figure.
I suspect that at a minimum Middleton wants to show the students his religion trumps theirs; if the chaplains indoctrinate the students, that’s gravy.
Likewise, Jim Jordan pretending him investigating academics for identifying Republican falsehoods is a win-win: no matter that he won’t find a smoking gun (or any gun) he’s already getting researchers to back off (“The fear of being targeted is profound enough that several researchers spoke on the condition that they not be named, and one prominent professor asked to be removed from the story entirely, citing concerns about his family’s safety.”)
I’ll wrap up with, first, a more positive (sort-of) story about Christian parents who’ve rejected homeschooling and no longer think the public schools are full of groomers and monsters. And second, two longer quotes:
“I’ve seen established academics—including the dean of a professional school at a university I worked for—explicitly defend the notion that humanities education should be stripped out of college degree requirements as a “social justice” measure. It’s wrong, they argued, to make less affluent students pay for “unnecessary” humanities courses. ” — from a discussion of how colleges are wrecking college education.
“the idea that the fundamental function of the university is to preserve, extend, and transmit cultural knowledge while teaching young people to think critically is itself a contested political position. Plenty of people in American culture and politics, mainly on the right but some on the left as well, don’t support this, because they believe that independent critical thinking is either bad in itself — this belief is the essence of reactionary politics of all stripes — or should give way to more pressing priorities” — Paul Campos in commentary about the previous link.