Who Goes Nazi? is a classic essay by Dorothy Thompson dissecting the different types of people willing to sell out to fascism: “The frustrated and humiliated intellectual, the rich and scared speculator, the spoiled son, the labor tyrant, the fellow who has achieved success by smelling out the wind of success—they would all go Nazi in a crisis.” (Thompson goes into more detail and I recommend the essay).
More recently Talia Lavin wrote Who Goes MAGA? which has since been deleted, but you can find parts of it at the link:
“Who we were born to, who we choose to be on emerging from that chrysalis, what we love and who, these shape us. Nevertheless, who we are is always a choice: every in-drawn breath is a choice, too. Nice people do not go MAGA, although people who are respectable and who are good at seeming nice go MAGA all the time.
That’s what makes the game so fascinating, the game of who goes MAGA: who would choose to drink the poisoned chalice when pushed up against the wall—and who reaches for it with both hands. And why. An upbringing or a code, innate instinct, rough experience, empathy or politesse can draw us away from vulgarity and cruelty. Pride and fear, venal self-absorption, a desire for vengeance, cowardice, conformity, jealousy and loneliness can draw us into hate.”
I think it’s more complicated than that. I’ve known several good people who’ve gone MAGA. Constant propaganda from religious leaders or Fox News, hanging out on conspiracy websites or podcasts, can turn someone into a twisted version of themselves. Someone a lot less good, if they’re still good at all.
Certainly nobody in Trump’s administration is a good guy. Border czar Doug Homan has threatened Alexandria Ocasia-Cortez simply for telling immigrants their rights. Ric Grennell thinks the head of Voice of America should be fired because he quoted a Trump critic. Darren Beattie who advocates sterilizing low-IQ trash. Given Beattie’s claim only competent white men are fit to run the country, I think he should be the first to get snipped. And we can snip misogynist anti-semite Scott Yenor next to him.
Pete Hegseth is thrilled about once again locking up detainees in Gitmo. Marco Rubio is cool with shipping even American citizens to El Salvador to lock them up. He reminds me of the stereotypical bureaucrat who rubber-stamps paperwork for the death camp, then protests that he never personally killed anyone!
Masha Gessen discusses more reasons people collaborate or cooperate with tyranny, for example by axing diversity initiatives. Because they have employees who’d lose their job if the state shuts them down. Because if they provide medical care for trans kids, they may lose the funding to care for others. Because you don’t stick your neck out on principle — give Trump what he wants! Because it’s better to be safe than sorry, like the Maryland National Guard canceling its salute to Frederick Douglass. Because it’s going to happen anyway — someone’s going to do it so what does it matter if it’s you?
All of these choices ultimately make things worse, including for the people you think you’re helping. And there are alternatives: it’s “possible to maintain a sense of facts and values — not only not to obey in advance but not to obey at all. If that was possible in the Soviet Union half a century ago, then it is certainly possible in the United States today.
As LawDork says, “Trump, through his orders, and Musk, through DOGE, are testing the limits and seeing what they can get away with. A step beyond claiming unearned powers, they are just presuming they have them and seeing if anyone stops them. It is an attempt at lawlessness — or, rather, at them being the law.“
At the state level, Utah State Rep. Trevor Lee wants an absolute ban on pride flags in classes but Confederate and Nazi flags in relation to the curriculum (history, say) would be legit. The Missouri Attorney General is suing Starbucks, claiming they have too many women and minorities working there and this hurts his state … somehow.
Too many Democrats (not all) in Congress wring their hands and do nothing. Or decide USAID isn’t anything the voters will care about so let Musk destroy it. Pock a worthwhile fight later. The Republicans of course happily embrace MAGA: Rep. Claudia Tenney wants to make his birthday a national holiday, to every Republican in the Senate voting to appoint anti-vaccine crackpot RFK Jr. as head of federal health services. Every Republican voted for Kennedy except Mitch McConnell. My state Senator, Thom Tillis, is bragging about supporting him; Ted Budd, the other senator, is keeping quiet but voted for Kennedy too.
The media go MAGA when they think the Musk-rats accessing government data without supervision or authority is less important than right-wing bullshit scandals. Or gush about how the Felon and Musk tromping over the law is a display of masculinity.
A lot of people sell out to MAGA or fascism because it’s in their interest. Trump wants NYC to cooperate in his anti-immigrant crackdowns; the DOJ has dropped its prosecution of Mayor Eric Adams. Silicon Valley are all in. Plus there are the people just waiting for permission to be evil (see here).
But as the Lavin essay notes, not everyone goes Maga. A-OC is speaking out. Senator Brian Schatz too. Rep. Robert Garcia mocked Musk this week (it won’t fix the problems but I doubt Musk has much stomach for it). While some Dems have supported some of Trump’s appointments, none of them voted for RFK Jr. Kathy Hochul, New York governor, is refusing to extradite an abortion doctor to Louisiana. Blue states are suing. The officials who resigned rather than drop the Adams lawsuit. Timothy Leonard of the National Parks Conservation Association has condemned FOTUS’ decision to drop references to trans people from the Stonewall Monument: “Erasing letters or webpages does not change the history or the contributions of our transgender community members at Stonewall or anywhere else. History was made here and civil rights were earned because of Stonewall.” Sheryl Crow selling her Tesla and donating the money to NPR.
It’s possible tyranny will win, but the fight is not over.