Category Archives: Reading

Young women, real and fictional

THE GIRLS: An All-American Town, a Predatory Doctor, and the Untold Story of the Gymnasts Who Brought Him Down by Abigail Pesta looks at the case of Larry Nassar, the respected doctor for the US gymnastics team and for gymnasts at Michigan State, who took advantage of his position to molest and sexually assault hundreds of girls. Pesta tells the story through the accounts of a dozen or so of Nassar’s victims, starting with the girl who may have been his first to one of the last before everything crashed down.

The book shows serious competitive gymnastics was often an abusive environment to start with, as coaches pushed their students beyond the limits of safety and verbally abused them for not getting it right, being too heavy, being too stressed, etc. Nassar, however, was a whole ‘nother level of horror, fingering girls in what he claimed was a therapeutic technique; that he was such a prolific predator proved an advantage as obviously if he felt up every girl it had to be a standard technique, nothing weird, right? Pesta shows how Nassar groomed and charmed the gymnasts, and their parents; while some girls did report him, it never led to anything. Infuriatinly, though unsurprisingly, it wasn’t even a coordinated cover-up (that came later, when Michigan State got seriously worried) — dozens of different people independently took no action, either because they didn’t believe the reports or they didn’t want to challenge someone with Nassar’s rep or who knows why. The book is well executed but grim.

Which may be why I’m going with something more uplifting for my illustration, Wisp asleep:

Leigh Bardugo’s THE FAMILIAR is a romantasy in a similar vein to Lies that Summon the Night and Arcana Academy, with the protagonist forced to wield her magical powers for a sinister, attractive man with everything she needs except her freedom (in the words of the old Flash Gordon serial). In this case, though, Luzia is a scullerymaid in late 1500s Spain and a converso, a Jew who practices the Catholic faith. The Inquisition, though, suspects all such Jews as fake Christians so if anyone ever spots anything suspicious about her, she’s in trouble.

That makes it a major problem when Luzia magically repairs a burned loaf of bread: her employer notices and before long Luzia is swept up by a more powerful noble and placed in a contest to select a holy champion to serve the Spanish king. It’s risky; if anyone suspects her powers don’t come from God, the Inquisition will take her. However it’s a path out of a life where she will never be anything but a kitchen drudge, sleeping on an earth floor. Then there’s Santangel, her new employer’s strange, supernatural agent. Cold, cruel, ruthless, he sees her as nothing but a tool for his master … doesn’t he?

This worked much better than the two earlier books using this set-up. The real-world setting adds punch and making it a done-in-one suited me more than having it launch yet another series. On the downside, the Luzia/Santangel romance feels very perfunctory and the magic needed more explanation. I don’t need an elaborate magic system but I wanted some explanation why Luzia has her powers (Christian god? Jewish god? Satan?). As is, she might as well be a mutant. Despite those flaws, I really enjoyed this.

Leave a comment

Filed under Reading, Undead sexist cliches

Covers across four genres

First, fantasy by Gervasio Gallardo (review of the book here).

Science fiction by Ed Emshwiller.

Murder mystery by Mitchell Hooks

And social realism (how realistic? I have no idea) by Bob Maguire. Yes that’s the same Fredric Wertham famous for his anti-comics crusading.

All rights to images remain with current holders.

Leave a comment

Filed under cover art, Reading

A bad book and an evil man: this week’s reading

It took Alan Garner years before he turned out a sequel to wrap up the story he began in Weirdstone of Brisingamen and Moon of Gomrath. Despite my distrust of authors returning to their long-ago early successes I’ve been thinking of reading the sequel; my library doesn’t have it but searching the website turned up Garner’s 2021 novella, THE TREACLE WALKER. Reading it was ninety minutes of my life I’ll never get back.

We open with Joseph, a young farmboy in the 1930s or 1940s, lying at home with a patch over one eye to strengthen the other “lazy” eye. Treacle Walker, the rag and bone man in the neighborhood shows up and suddenly we’re immersed in a strange series of weird, surreal events. Joseph barters with Treacle Walker for a magic stone, discovers his covered eye can see things that aren’t there, falls into a comic strip and talks to a dead man buried in the nearby bog. Which is material that should add up to a fascinating story, but doesn’t. There is no plot to hold everything together, making it just a string of weird, unexplained events. It’s also way too heavy on dialog with minimal detail on setting which as with Owl Service makes it harder to figure out what the heck is going on. I’m baffled by the tons of critical acclaim this got.

THE GIRLS: An All-American Town, a Predatory Doctor, and the Untold Story of the Gymnasts Who Brought Him Down by Abigail Pesta looks at the story of Larry Nassar — a respected doctor who molested hundreds of gymnasts brought to him for help with their injuries — through the stories of some of his victims, from one who may have been his first target through to one of the last one. Pesta shows how Nassar groomed his targets, won over their parents and thrived despite repeated complaints to police, Michigan State University (he was a sports doctor there for years) and gymnastic bodies. In most cases it doesn’t appear there was a coordinated cover-up, just the ubiquity of rape culture: either the gymnasts weren’t believed or the people they reported to didn’t want to rock the boat by confronting someone so respected. The result, of course, was that Nassar operated for years longer; the fact he molested so many girls worked in his favor as many victims assumed his vaginal and anal “treatment” must be legit — all the patients they talked to had been through it. Horrible stuff but a good book.

Cover by Jack Gaughan, all rights to image remain with current holders.

Leave a comment

Filed under Reading

A closer look at some cover art

I posted this 1955 Lu Kimmel cover back in June. It occurred to me last week that I had more to say about it.

First, of course, we have the Sex Sells aspect — just how much is the protagonist seeing? Then there’s his body language: obviously focused on her but clutching the satchel defensively (though the Amazon synopsis makes me think it’s a safety deposit box). She’s sending an invitation; he’s not sure it’s a good idea.

The cover copy gives it context. It tells us he’s a thief and a womanizer, not some innocent. That suggests to me he was walking out with his prize when he discovered he wasn’t alone in the house. Maybe not, but it does inject some added drama into the scene. I don’t see lines like that on covers any more but there’s something to be said for them.

We don’t know anything about the woman from the cover art. However any woman whose posing in front of a man like that qualifies as a bad girl by 1955 standards. Typically in a paperback thriller she’ll be part of the conflict — love vs money, wanting a woman he shouldn’t have, etc. I don’t have the urge to hunt for more information but if I saw it cheap in a used bookstore, I might pick it up.

All rights to image remain with current holder.

Leave a comment

Filed under cover art, Reading

Cranes, cannabalism and fictitious history: books read

SIX CRIMSON CRANES by Elizabeth Lim is a Y/A whose protagonist, Shiori, is princess in a fantasy analog of China. Magic is banned so it’s a shock for Shiori to realize not only does she have powers — she’s able to bring a paper bird to life as her sidekick — but so does her stepmother. And those powers may be why Shiori and her six brothers all love stepmommy so much …

Stepmother is, of course, not happy with these discoveries and takes steps: turning the brothers into cranes, exiling Shiori and putting an added curse on her, that if she speaks her brothers will die. Now the princess has to find her brothers, find a cure, break the curse on her and settle with her stepmother.

Although one big reveal was obvious from the first chapter, this worked for me. However the characters come off awfully contemporary — make Shiori and her brothers rich kids from Beverly Hills and it wouldn’t change much. Still, I’m up for reading more in the series eventually.

CANNIBALISM AND THE COMMON LAW: The Story of the Tragic Last Voyage of the Mignonette and the Strange Legal Proceedings to Which It Gave Rise by A.W. Brian Simpson recounts how in 1884, Captain Thomas Dudley and two crewmen were rescued from a lifeboat after the wreck of the yacht Mignonette, which they’d been crewing for a trip to Australia. Recounting their ordeal, they freely admitted they’d engaged in “the custom of the sea,” killing and eating the fourth member of the crew. They had no reason to think this would be a problem for them; as Simpson shows, it happened a lot in the 19th century and the British simply shrugged — tough situation, tough choices, “doctrine of necessity” applies. And for much of the century, the British court system had little say in what happened at sea, though by 1884 that had changed some. The only real objection to the trio’s cannibalism was that according to some versions of their story (they retold it several times) they hadn’t drawn lots to pick the victim but had just killed the weakest link.

What was also changing was that the government was increasingly uncomfortable with a legal doctrine that said killing was okay if it was necessary. Having tried a few years earlier to make a case against cannibalism and failed (it bogged down in imperial bureaucracy) they decided this time they’d succeed. To the surprise of Dudley and his men, they were charged with murder and sort-of found guilty (the judge put his thumb heavily on the scale) so the case could then be kicked up high enough to get a definitive ruling. Everyone involved did this with the intention of getting the trio pardoned — the goal was to establish a principle, not to punish them for their actions — but there was less enthusiasm at higher levels of government. The men ended up serving six months, then went free.

Unlike, say, the book Honor Killing, this is surprisingly lacking in drama. Simpson is approaching this as a legal historian covering a landmark case, not as a true-crime writer. It is not, however, lacking in interest. The book covers the rise of recreational yachting in the 19th century, multiple earlier cases of cannibalism, legal theories as to when cannibalism was justified, land-based cannibalism cases (I learned more about American cannibal Alf Packer than I ever did before), the frequency of shipwrecks (I can see why the Titanic being unsinkable made it such a big deal) and the complexities of the British legal system. Obviously not for everyone but it fits my particular tastes in nerdy reading.

DC Comics continuity has been in disarray ever since the Crisis on Infinite Earths, or more precisely, the endless reboots that followed it. Back in the 1990s, Dan Jurgens tried stabilizing it with the Zero Hour crossover event but reboots kept happening, both system wide (Infinite Crisis, Flashpoint, Convergence) and individual (John Byrne had the Doom Patrol’s history erased so he could start them over from scratch). With THE NEW HISTORY OF THE DC UNIVERSE, Mark Waid and multiple illustrators are giving it another shot.

This gathers the various additions and retcons that have accumulated over the years and turns them into a single timeline. As many of them occurred in the last 15 years or so, and I haven’t been following comics closely (precisely because endless reboots make it hard to get attached to a character), this was interesting to see. Waid also has to account for the multiple reality resets since Infinite Crisis rebooted the post COIE world but explains that the disruptions have finally ceased and stability has been achieved. I’ll be delighted, but I’ll believe it when I see it.

This is obviously not something to read unless you’re seriously curious about this stuff; like Cannibalism and the Common Law this is a book giving you information, not drama. I was glad to have read it, though — and like I said, I hope this does set the stage for a DCU where continuity is no more tangled than it always is.

All rights to images remain with current holders. COIE cover by George Perez.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Reading

Triptychs!

Two trilogies from Ballantine Books, two sets of triple covers. First, The Lord of the Rings by Barbara Remington.

These covers go back to when LOTR was still seen as a one-of-a-kind thing. Epic fantasy didn’t exist as a genre; there was Tolkien and people knocking off Tolkien, that was it. They are very much what I think of as the covers. Remington says she hadn’t had a chance to read the books when she drew the art or she’d have drawn them differently.

Second, the three Gormenghast novels by Mervyn Peake, with covers by Bob Pepper.

Here’s a better look at the image without the titles.

If you think that looks weird, well so are the books: Titus Groan, Gormenghast — apparently I never blogged about V3, Titus Alone Peake’s wife put together a fourth volume from his notes and the novella Boy in Darkness falls between V1 and V2.

Part of the inspiration for this post was someone on FB saying that after reading LOTR they’d picked up the Peake books as another fantasy trilogy — that must mean a lot like LOTR, right? It must have been a jarring transition.

All rights to images remain with current holders.

Leave a comment

Filed under cover art, Reading

Edward Gorey, Father Brown and Deathlok! Books read

BORN TO BE POSTHUMOUS: The Eccentric Life and Mysterious Genius of Edward Gorey by Mark Dery reminds me of my friend Ross’s observation that epic biographies should be reserved for people who live epic lives Four hundred pages isn’t epic by 21st century standards but it’s still too big for Gorey’s life.

Gorey was certainly a fascinating person, flamboyant in personal style and grotesquely whimsical in his art. I was surprised to realize he’d died in 2000 — his work seems very much out of another era, which is part of its charm. Despite all of which, his life story isn’t as interesting as the man himself. Dysfunctional family. Flowering in college. Endless details of the plays and the artists he liked, the books he read, the literary friends he made (I’m impressed he had the poet John Ciardi as one of his college teachers). As I often say, it’s not the author’s fault I’m not as interested in the details of the topic as they are; still, the details really don’t seem interesting.

A bigger problem is Dery’s determination to see Gorey as a gay icon. Gorey described himself as uninterested or asexual when the subject came up, though his history shows that may not have been the case. It’s a legit topic for a biographer but Dery really obsesses over it: look at his gay friends, his gay sense of style, his love of Oscar Wilde, his arch, gay sense of humor… by the time we get to any gay subtext in his art I no longer cared. A third, minor problem, is that like many nonfiction writers, Dery tries to make the subject bigger than it is — without Gorey, the graphic-novel industry would never have been open to something as gay as Alison Bechdel’s Fun Home! For various reasons, I think that’s nonsense.

G. K. Chesterton’s second Father Brown collection, THE INCREDULITY OF FATHER BROWN has a number of moments I love. There’s Father Brown explaining the difference between a real mystic and a fake (real mystics tell you everything and you’re mystified; fakes hide everything and when you see it you’re bored), his discourse on vigilantes in “The Arrow of God,” on dressing gowns as a perfect disguise in “The Dagger With Wings” and the killer’s motivation in “The Oracle of the Dog” (“If he had really known the money would come to him, I actually believe he wouldn’t have done it.”). Some of the stories, such as “The Doom of the Darnaways” don’t work half as well. Plus we have Chesterton’s religious biases, for example frowning over the 19th century American secularist Robert Ingersoll (more vicious an enemy of religion than Voltaire!). And did you know Jews were subject to fair less persecution in medieval Europe than Christians (for anyone who doesn’t know religious history, this is blatant anti-Semitic bullshit)? Overall I enjoyed it but I can see why some people avoid the series like the plague.

MARVEL MASTERWORKS: Deathlok the Demolisher by Rich Buckler (who did the striking cover here) and a variety of collaborators, including Doug Moench and Bill Mantlo, was one I read for this month’s Genre Book Club; the theme was cyberpunk and this 1974-76 series is very much proto-cyberpunk.

Luther Manning had been a capable military officer. When war hit the United States in the 1990s, he wound up stepping on a mine after which his CO, Major Ryker, rebuilt him as a cyborg (in a moment that’s now hilarious, the cyborg’s computer program runs on punch cards inserted into his prosthetic arm). “Deathlok” did a good job at first eliminating Ryker’s enemies, then Luther’s consciousness reasserted itself. Now he has two missions: take down Ryker and regain his humanity.

This has many cyberpunk elements: powerful computers, advanced tech, a decaying, violent urban setting, omnipresent surveillance. It’s most distinctive high-tech element is that even after Luther regains his mind, the computer is still in his head. The dialogue between Manning and the “‘puter” is the thing many people who glanced at the series on the stands remember.

In the Bronze Age, it was different from anything else out there, much bleaker than, say, the Atomic Knights (who were in reprint in Strange Adventures in the 1970s). There’s a lot I like, some nice touches (Luther’s in an interracial marriage) but the plotting is often wonky. Ryker’s girlfriend discover he’s a cyborg, then spends the rest of the series comatose, hooked up to a computer to enable more intuitive control of the weapons it commands or something like that. And she’s the chief woman character in the series for most of the run. And it’s really disappointing that while Ryker talks about merging with his computer and becoming “the God Machine,” the reveal is anticlimactic — apparently the entire series is about a turf war for control over New York, nothing more imaginative. A mixed bag, but one I’m glad to have read (this also includes Deathlok’s adventures in the present after his series ended, but I won’t get into that here).

Art by Gorey and Buckler, all rights to images remain with current holders.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Reading

My battle plan survived, sort of

As I’ve talked about before, one of the military rules of thumb is that no battle plan survives first contact with the enemy. I knew this week would demolish any regular plan, so I adjusted accordingly.

(Photos are all from our yard, like this morning’s post. Here we have Mr. Squirrel acrobatically chowing down on the suet we put out for the birds)

This week, we began a renovation project. The master bathroom bathtub has enough problems we decided it was worth fixing them now rather than waiting until they become serious major problems. If you’ve ever heard that major renovations are a massive pain, it’s true. Knowing that I decided to work on Savage Adventures because it’s nonfiction and editing the manuscript doesn’t take creative thought the way resuming work on Let No Man Put Asunder would.

It was as bad as I’d figured and then some. As TYG normally works her IT gig in the master bedroom, she relocated into the spare bedroom and moved her bathroom stuff into mine. I’d almost forgotten how many things she has on her bathroom counter so mine is quite cluttered now.

A much bigger issue is that with people coming in and out, we worried the cats would freak, particularly Snowdrop, and bolt out away from the strangers. If they were spending the day sleeping upstairs we could simply lock them in. The past couple of weeks they’ve been hanging out in the living room so I had to keep constant watch they weren’t sitting too close to the door. Fortunately neither of them tried to get out, though they clearly weren’t happy.

That, coupled with dealing with the contractor if they had questions or requests (TYG did some of that, but with Zoom meetings to attend she can’t do all of it), plus the jarring noises from upstairs left me somewhat frazzled. Because I concentrated on Savage Adventures I was at least somewhat productive. I went through the book and made sure all the Doc Savage novels were attributed correctly; while Lester Dent wrote most of them, Street and Smith assigned other writers to some, and Dent occasionally used ghostwriters. I edited the first three chapters as well. The rest of the time I did some blogging, paid bills, etc. Nothing super-demanding. If not a spectacular workweek, I don’t feel I fell down on the job either.

Over at Atomic Junk Shop I blogged about toxic masculinity, reposted some book reviews from this blog, and posted about Southern Discomfort coming out (same post as I put up here, more or less). And that’s about it.

The contractors will be back Monday-Wednesday next week. I’m slightly more ambitious about what I plan to do. Wish me luck living up to my plans.

1 Comment

Filed under Doc Savage, Nonfiction, Personal, Time management and goals, Writing

Two covers for Wednesday

One by Harry Schaare showing a typical work session at a typical office, as imagined in pop culture decades ago. For secretary stereotypes I recommend Lynn Peril’s Swimming in the Steno Pool.

Here’s a Barye Phillips cover going less for sex, more for thrills.

All rights to images remain with current holders.

Leave a comment

Filed under cover art, Reading

Two books about our world gone wrong

Years ago, Harlan Ellison wrote that the difference between classic Hollywood and today was not that classic Hollywood didn’t turn out trash but that even the people who made trash knew art was real, knew it mattered, and knew they weren’t making art. Susan Jacoby’s THE AGE OF AMERICAN UNREASON from 2008 makes the same point at greater length and less effectively.

Jacoby’s argument is that while anti-intellectualism has always been a strain in American life, Americans traditionally valued education and culture. They wanted to learn, they wanted to acquire sophistication, they wanted to see their kids become better educated than they were. That might mean college, trips to museums or “middlebrow” sources of culture such as the last century’s Book of the Month Club. People, at least some of them, were willing to learn about classic literature and classical music.

That belief in the life of the mind, Jacoby argues, has collapsed under the combined impact of sixties radicalism, fundamentalist religion, drugs, non-intellectual pursuits such as movies, TV and videogames, the cult of celebrity, and nobody being willing to uphold intellectual rigor. Colleges offer puff courses for an easy A; intellectuals refuse to call out bullshit, preferring to tolerate nonsense (religion, in Jacoby’s eyes, gets way too much of a free pass).

Don’t get me wrong, I’m sympathetic to her view. If anything, it’s gotten worse as we plunge into a world where any crackpot can use YouTube or a podcast to reach millions with idiotic takes, students use AI for their term papers, and the administration actively denies facts in favor of political right-wing orthodoxy. At the same time there were lots of little things that nagged at me, like assuming videogames are strictly a guy thing (lots of women played them) or that religion is inherently anti-rational (the Abrahamic religions start with faith and divine revelation but they’ve poured a lot of logical thought into them). And how much the media contributed to this decline even before they began sanewashing the Toddler. From what I’ve read, they didn’t pick W as the winner of the first Bush/Gore debate, the media told them repeatedly that he’d won (the rationale, IIRC, was that they had low expectations and W surpassed them, so there you are).

This also comes off a lot as an intellectual snob’s rant about Kids These Days — sure, the Beatles are nice, but why aren’t people listening to classical music? Reading serious literature (I think she’d be either astonished or annoyed that I’m comfortable reading both nonfiction and comic books)? Taking fluff courses instead of serious academics (as someone who took several fluff courses, they can make a fun break from the serious stuff. It doesn’t mean I didn’t have hard ones). Ultimately I wanted to like the book much more than I actually liked it.


KIDS FOR CASH: Two Judges, Thousands of Children and a $2.6 million Kickback Scheme by William Ecenbarger induced rage in me much as Empire of Pain did. Ecenbarger shows how Pennsylvania Justice Mark Conahan and juvenile court judge Mark Ciaravella shut down their county’s juvenile detention center, then became silent partners in a local for-profit center the county contracted with (their decision — Ciaravella’s position gave him a lot of clout in such things). To make up for the huge kickbacks the company owners had paid them, the judges made sure lots of kids had stays there, regardless of how trivial the offense. Flipped a passing police car the bird? Got into an argument with your step-parent? Threw a piece of lunchmeat at a fellow student? Three days to a week in juvie, maybe as punishment, maybe so that their psychiatrist (a relative of one of the judges IIRC) could evaluate you — something that could normally done as an outpatient.

To be fair, Ciaravella wasn’t just a corrupt judge, he was a shitty judge. He sentenced kids who’d committed trivial offenses to months in detention at facilities he didn’t have any investment in. He did this without any regard for their rights. Probation officers assured kids they’d get lighter sentences without an attorney — this was a lie — and if they insisted on having a public defender, Ciaravella often ignored the PD or talked over them. The kids would usually leave the courtroom in shackles. Their permanent record was tarnished; kids their age assumed they were serious criminals and shunned them; and many of them grappled with trauma, guilt and shame as a result.

Ciavarella didn’t care. Conahan didn’t care. Almost nobody else did. The system collaborated willingly. Schools got rid of troublemakers, however trivial the trouble was; prosecutors got their conviction stats up; probation officers kept their caseload down; staffers in the courts protected their jobs by not pushing back against the powerful; the judicial review board which was supposed to investigate things like this did nothing. The entire system was corrupt, which was typical of that part of Pennsylvania (teachers mention in passing that it took a $5,000 payment to the school board to land a job).

Happily, there were officials, reporters and activists who pushed back. It took far too long but both judges were eventually convicted of some of their crimes. Ciavarella remains in prison; Conahan unfortunately got shifted to home arrest during the pandemic, and got his sentence commuted under Biden. Those who fought the good fight were a light in the heart of darkness, and this was a shitty darkness indeed.

All rights to cover images remain with current holders.

1 Comment

Filed under Reading